Authors: Tara Conklin
“We better be. I’ve been talking to Dave”—Lina knew that there was only one Dave at Clifton & Harp, Dave Whitehead, the firm’s managing partner, head of all thirty-seven worldwide offices and more than two thousand lawyers, known to the associates as El Gran Jefe—“and he’s right behind me on this. I told him I’m waiting, I’m waiting, I’m still waiting on you, Dan. And today you’re telling me I’ve got to wait some more? I want this to be the last call we have, Dan, the last call where I hear the word
wait
.”
“I hear you, Ron. Loud and clear.” Dan raised his gaze from the phone and his eyes fell on Lina. He waved her over with a tired flap of his hand. Pouches of purplish skin hung beneath his eyes, saggy as used-up tea bags. Lina approached the desk and settled into her usual chair, the too-low backrest familiar, comfortable (almost) if she stayed perfectly upright, if she did not attempt any type of relaxation.
“Here’s Lina,” Dan said. “She’s just back from her trip to Richmond. She’s ready to update us on her findings. Lina?” And he pushed the phone in her direction.
Lina shifted, unbuttoned the tuxedo jacket, which she realized now smelled distinctly of smoke, and wished with a passion rarely attributed to beverages that she had stopped for coffee.
“It was a very useful trip,” she began, feeling her hangover recede as she spoke. “I found some extremely helpful documents at the Bell Center archives. These documents appear to establish that Josephine Bell had a child in 1848, and that child was sold to a Mr. Caleb Harper.”
“Cut to the chase, Lina,” Dresser barked from the speaker phone. “Do we have a plaintiff? Do we have any names?” Lina felt Dan’s unblinking gaze heavy on her, and she met his stare head-on. She was aware of Garrison in the chair beside her, watching.
“Well, yes,” Lina said. “I do have a name. Battle. Jasper Battle. He’s a musician. He’s in New York.”
Dan’s mouth fell open, his eyebrows shot up. “Fantastic!”
“Excellent work,” Dresser said, his voice fainter now, as if he had stepped away from the phone. There was the rustle of other people entering the room, soft footsteps on thick carpet. “Lina, what do you think of his backstory? Is he verifiable as a Bell descendant?”
“Yes, I think so. There’s still some work to be done in that regard.” Her voice wavered and she cleared her throat. “But on the face of it he seems … legitimate.” Lina felt heat in her cheeks and wondered with a rising panic how she would prove that Jasper was Josephine’s descendant. Would he ever talk to her again? Why had she not taken hold of his face, why had she left his apartment?
“Well, I look forward to meeting him,” Dresser said.
Dan thrust his head toward the phone and said, with a conviction bordering on maniacal: “Ron, you have my word—give us a few more days.
My word,
we will have this brief for you by Tuesday. At the
latest
.”
Garrison tapped Lina’s arm and she turned toward him.
Tuesday?
he silently mouthed with great exaggeration and implied outrage. Today was Friday. Tuesday was soon. Four days for them, Garrison and Lina, to draft and edit the brief on a legally complex, highly contentious, potentially historic claim that other (presumably) talented lawyers had previously argued and, in all instances, lost.
“Great, I look forward to reading it,” Dresser said. “I’ve got to run now, people. Dan, thanks for the call.”
The line switched to a painfully loud dial tone, all three of them jolting in their chairs with the sudden awful noise. Dan groped for the off button, the phone went dead, and for a moment it seemed they might all have suffered some irreversible damage to the ear or head. Lina felt the cruel return of her hangover.
“Well, I’m happy to hear the trip paid off, Lina,” Dan said and scratched his scalp vigorously, red curls thrown into frenzied motion. “Let’s get this Battle person in here
asap
. Tuesday, team. You heard me. You’re working through the weekend, obviously. We’ve got four more days.”
B
ACK AT HER DESK, HER
office door closed, the enormity of Lina’s lie fell upon her with a sudden suffocating weight. She could not yet prove that Jasper was descended from Josephine Bell and, perhaps even more important, he had made clear his complete disinterest in becoming involved in the lawsuit. What had happened that morning—her hasty departure, the collapsed look on Jasper’s face—did not bear contemplating. Not now. She had to focus or this case would fall apart. Without a lead plaintiff, there would be no reparations lawsuit.
Lina picked up the phone and dialed Jasper’s number.
A
FTER SOME AWKWARD PLEASANTRIES AND
a beseeching “please” from Lina, Jasper had agreed to meet her at NYU’s main library, a tall tower of red stone known for its soaring open-air atrium and the highly literate and pornographic graffiti found in the third-floor bathrooms. Lina almost didn’t recognize him as he walked toward her across the wide marble-floored expanse. Gone was his musician’s swagger and all-black ensemble. Now he wore khakis, a white button-down shirt, the cuffs nearly covering his tattoos; he carried a canvas briefcase. Lina waited by the circulation desk as his steps echoed against the stone.
Jasper stopped in front of her and leaned his head toward the glass revolving doors. “Let’s sit outside.” As they moved away from the desk, he unpinned a plastic name tag from his shirt and waved to a dark-haired woman who was shelving books.
Lina watched the exchange. “Wait—do you
work
here?” she asked.
“Yeah. I’m a part-time reference librarian. I was in a Ph.D. program, music history, but I’m taking a break. Not sure I want to finish it. Seven years is a long time.”
“Will they let you back in after your break?”
“Maybe. Not sure.”
“That would make me crazy. The not knowing.” They were walking briskly now, moving against the flow of sidewalk traffic. Lina maneuvered through the lunchtime crowds, not looking at Jasper.
“Not knowing what?” he asked.
“Where I was going, what I was doing. You know, the uncertainty.”
“It’s okay,” he said. “And who says I’m not
going
somewhere?” Abruptly Jasper stopped. “You think I’m some kind of loser, don’t you?” he asked, and Lina stopped too, half a pace ahead, and turned to face him.
“No, of course I don’t.” Lina was taken aback by the defensiveness on his face, the hurt in his voice. She felt painted into her own little corner, and she had put herself there. She stepped toward Jasper, into the path of a man in a blue suit, who swerved and cursed and continued on his way.
“Jasper, that’s the last thing I think,” Lina said. “I think you’re … brave.” She remembered how, onstage, each stroke of his bass had echoed with a deep, exquisite tremor.
The flow of strangers continued around them. Jasper’s face softened. “Let’s go to the park,” he said. He resumed walking and Lina fell into step beside him.
They crossed the street to Washington Square Park, the buzz of skateboarders and teenagers swirling across the pavement. A man with dreadlocks and a limp ambled past, eating a strawberry ice cream cone. The chess tables were full. Lina and Jasper sat on a stretch of green-slatted bench.
“I need to talk to you again about the reparations case,” Lina said, and inhaled as though she were diving into a pool. “I did a stupid thing. I told the partner and the client on this case that I had verified a Josephine Bell descendant and that he had agreed to be our lead plaintiff. And that the descendant is you.”
The silence that followed seemed impossibly complete for such a crowded, public space. Lina heard the creak of the bench beneath her as she shifted in place, waiting for Jasper’s response. “That is kind of stupid,” Jasper said at last, though he did not appear alarmed. His left eyebrow rose in a smooth arched curve.
“Wait, how do you do that?” Lina asked. “The one eyebrow?”
The eyebrow flattened. “It’s weird, I know. It happens when I’m curious. I’m curious as to what you’re going to do now. You’ve got a lot of ground to cover.” Jasper was matter-of-fact, but not unkind.
“I know,” Lina said weakly. The same swirling she’d felt that night at the bar with Jasper and outside his building, of events flying beyond her control, came over her again. Her right foot began to rapidly tap the concrete. Calmly, Jasper studied her.
“Can I ask you a question, Lina? Why do you do this? I mean, this job? Doesn’t it make you crazy?”
“This job? Well …” She met his eyes and then looked away, to where the pigeons scurried at their feet, swallowing bread crumbs with great backward curls of their oily necks. That old story—Oscar’s comment, the pants off any judge—suddenly seemed ridiculous. Why did Lina do this job?
“I really loved law school,” she began. “Right and wrong, resolution, justice. The rule of law. All that stuff. I worked on an asylum case for an immigration law clinic I did my third year. My client was a woman from Sudan. Ange was her name—the last client I had with a name that didn’t end in Corp. or LLP. She was young and afraid, her story was atrocious in every way, there was nowhere for her to go, and somehow she found her way here, to New York. She looked at me as though I had the answer to every question. But I thought she was amazing, just the fact of her being here, alive, after all she had seen and endured. That’s why I do this job, or why I
thought
I did it.”
“Did you win the case? Did she get asylum?” Jasper’s eyebrow flew up again into a neat arch.
“Yes. She lives in Flatbush now.” Lina remembered the night she went to Ange’s apartment for dinner, a few weeks after the asylum decision, and Ange had cooked a spicy stew with beef and cinnamon and shown her a faded, cracked photograph of her mother, who was pretty and smiling, her head draped with an orange scarf.
Lina looked up. Jasper was watching her with his honey-colored eyes. “I’ve been thinking about it,” he said. “I talked it over with my mom. I’ll be your plaintiff, Lina. If you want me to be. I mean, if I
am
related to Josephine Bell.”
Lina did not know immediately what to say. She was not accustomed to asking for help, she did not know how to respond when it was offered. “Thank you” was all she could summon.
“You’re welcome,” Jasper said with a mock-serious smile, and stood. “Okay, I’ve got to get back.”
Lina rose and moved to hug him. He did a funny dance, half moving away, but then gently he kissed her on the cheek.
“Good luck, Lina,” he whispered into her ear.
A
T HOME, IN THE MIDDLE
of a workday! Lina couldn’t believe her nerve. The house was quiet, no sign of Oscar, and lit up with sun in a way that seemed oddly vivid, as though light fell more urgently on weekdays.
She ran up the stairs. Nora’s document, which lay inside the white envelope, which sat inside her handbag, which rested on the floor of her bedroom, remained unread. This was why Lina had come home on a Friday afternoon. Tomorrow she was meeting Garrison at six
A.M
. at the office to begin drafting the brief.
But first: cotton gloves. Cotton gloves? Lina rifled through her boxes of winter things, her underwear drawer, her sock drawer. No gloves, but she found a clean pair of thin cotton socks that she slipped onto her hands. Nora would approve, Lina felt sure.
With cumbersome socked hands, Lina opened the envelope and slipped out the pages. There were twenty at least, a thick packet of crinkly paper, covered in neat, even handwriting. They smelled dry and faintly sweet, almost like burnt sugar. Sitting cross-legged on her bed, Lina began to read.
M
ARCH
15, 1853
S
TANTON
, V
IRGINIA
The moon hangs low and lights this page. I have put away the candle for it is a full moon, a harvest moon my father would have called it, beaming down brighter almost than a midday sun. Tonight is the last I will spend under my brother’s roof with you asleep in the room beside. I have not said my good-byes, though this, I think, is for the best. Forgiveness is not easily earned, not for me, and I have no wish to trouble Jack further with my presence here. It is hard for him to bear, I can see it in the set of his jaw, the way he turns his face away from me. He is busy with preparations for your journey west, to the Oregon territory and a new life there, and I distract and remind him of what he seeks to forget. Perhaps you have sensed already that I will not travel with you. I suspect so. Children know more than we adults care to fathom, and you I feel are wise already.
I know well that the circumstances of a child’s birth and raising, the hopes and frustrations of his parents, their fears and desires, shape in ways great and small the kind of man that child in time becomes. I do not want you always to wonder how you came to Jack, about the events that set your life in forward motion, away from your mother and the place where you were born. You should know all that I know, and it is this aim that guides my pen tonight.
In such an exercise, there are limitations, and of these I am manifestly aware. I am not practiced in the narrative arts and what I set down here may turn rough or discursive. There are things you will read about myself, about Jack and Dorothea, about Josephine and Mr. and Mrs. Bell that may cause you some distress. Once you have finished with these pages, you may think of me in a new light, a harsher light. You may wish that my conduct had been different, better, braver than it was. When you are older, you will, I hope, learn something of the world and understand that each man carries with him imperfection and regret, and day by day he strives to make right the wrongs he has committed, to repair what he has broken. This is what I have struggled to do, in ways human and flawed.
It is difficult for me to consider my past and not be consumed by a great and abiding sadness, a sense that nothing I have touched will stand for good. That no amount of amends I perform will account for the wrongs already done. I hope that wherever else I have failed, whatever harm I have caused to strangers and friends, that you may speak for me. Not before a pulpit or upon a stage. Not with words great or loud. But only to be, to persist, to live a life with pride and worth. In twenty years’ time, thirty, or forty, I hope that you may sit upon the porch of your home, look out upon a greening field that you have tilled, see your children surrounding you with love, and think for a moment upon me. That is all now that I truly wish for. To be for a moment in your thoughts, when I have long passed from this earth, and perhaps in that way I may find my redemption, an earthly redemption, not everlasting, but sacred nonetheless.
Here then is the story, Josephine’s story, your story, and mine.
The day I first saw Josephine is etched clear and bright in my mind. It was a late summer morning in the year 1852. I had slept scarcely an hour when Little Sullivan, one of Mr. Rust’s boys, called round for me. He knocked so hard on the guesthouse door that I awoke thinking there was a fire or flood or some other manifestation of God’s wrath bearing down on me. I looked out the window and saw Little below, motioning up at me. We need you, Doc, Little called. Down at the barn.
Little was not a man known for patience or good humor. I gathered my things with haste. My head ached from the previous night’s drink and my knees seemed partial to giving way as I stepped slowly down the stairs and onto the porch. The stale taste of whiskey still filled my mouth and I spat into the dry grass. That September had seen summer stretch further than it ought, and the haze on the horizon, the cloudless sky, indicated another humid and close day. But the morning had not yet turned to hot and I thanked the God that still remained to me for the air cool on my face. I nodded at Little as he brought my horse round and before mounting I shook my head to clear the haze that hung there too.
I followed Little to a field about three miles east outside of town, to a place I had come to know well. There had once been a farm here but not in my lifetime and all that remained now of that failed venture was a falling-down pile of rotting timber where the house had once stood and a gray leaning barn, its walls and roof slanting towards the earth at such an angle that the lessons of physics surely could not explain why it still stood.
The sun was right and truly risen when we reached the barn and I narrowed my eyes against it as I looked at what the patroller Josiah had brought. This was when I saw her first, the girl, Josephine. She was hitched to the back of Josiah’s old mare, a sorry sway-backed animal that twitched its ears in mad frustration as the wind hit them. Her dress seemed the dress of a house girl, not homespun, but it was stained with sweat and blood, and the hem was frayed and torn. She wore fine boots, and Josiah pulled them off her as I watched and stuffed them inside his pack.
There were three runaways that morning, Josephine and two men, one who’d been beat within an inch of his life and the other named Bo. The men were sat on the ground beside the barn, their backs against the gray slatted wall, the first either asleep or unconscious, I couldn’t say which.
I could tell right away that Josephine was poorly. Her right eye was crusted over shut, yellow pus seeping from the corners, and she seemed only half-aware, something vital gone from her face and the good eye that rolled upwards as she stood and swayed beside the mare. Josiah let her loose and brought her to the edge of the barn where I waited next to a three-legged stool left out by Mr. Rust for these occasions. She sat, shaking as her knees bent to shift her weight.
Watch this one, Josiah said and pointed his chin towards the girl. She came on us with a knife.
I examined her in the methodical way I’d been taught at the medical college, working from head to toe and left to right. She seemed to notice me no more than you would a bird passing overhead or a beetle crawling beside your toe. Part of her had already departed this world and her head swung from side to side like a doll’s as I looked in one ear then the other. She moaned once, I remember, a deep throaty sound that reminded me of heaven and hell, of the preacher’s moans when his eyes rolled up after sermoning on sinning and its consequences.
As I conducted my examinations, Josiah stood to the side awaiting his payment and working his hat in his hands. He was a small man, stoop-shouldered and bony, like his horse. I heard Mr. Rust tell once that Josiah was burdened by a wife who would not stop bearing children, nine at the last count, and a dry farm that barely yielded enough for two hungry stomachs. He had come to patrolling out of need, not design, and I felt a degree of sympathy for him. This was not a job for a family man, nor for any man with a heart and sense of justice.
Once I’d finished, Mr. Rust inquired with eyebrows raised as to the value of the goods on offer. I nodded towards the girl and Bo, but not the other. The risk with him was too high, the Lord’s breath was in his face already or it’d take him so long to recover from his beating that any profit would be spent on feeding and housing him in the meantime. I wasn’t sure what made me choose Josephine, she could have been the same as the other, too much risk. Maybe something in that moan, a spirit sound from deep down, or maybe the way she kicked her legs when I tapped the kneecaps, like she was still running, showed me she was mostly alive in there.
I cannot say that it was then, that morning, I began to love her. Such thoughts were the furthest from my mind. I saw only limbs, a head, a body requiring repair, and I the one charged to do it.
I should explain something about my position, how I came to be there with Josephine and the others at the barn on that wind-riven day. We were thieves, of a sort, though the kind sanctioned by the federal legislature. Since passage of the Fugitive Slave Act, all manner of men had turned their hand to slave catching, the sole requirement for the subject of their attentions being simply a Negro face. It made no difference the true status of the man, woman, or child—be they rightfully free, or another man’s property, or indeed a slave escaped from any manner of indignities that no creature should be made to bear. On the sugar fields and great cotton plantations of Mississippi, Louisiana, South Carolina, Florida, the need for slaves was great, the sums paid beyond imagining. Five, six, sometimes ten times the prices in Virginia could be fetched at market in New Orleans. It was a simple calculus for the men engaged in such larceny.
I was employed by one of their number, a slavecatcher by the name of Benjamin Rust. He stood tall and bony, a beady-eyed man with a long dark mustache, droopy at the ends, that traveled up and down as he spoke. He had no God and never spoke a kind word if it wouldn’t serve his own benefit but for all his wanderings and deals, his ambitions were not great. The accumulation of wealth and the things it purchased were his only cares. Most days I could barely stand to look at him, but I worked beside him, I did as he bade me, I took the notes he paid.
A long cloud has drifted across the moon and tempers its rays so I have lit a candle to continue. The flame is weak and flickering but it will serve until the clouds recede again.
As I look at the black, hard center of the flame, it is clear to me that I must go back, I must redraw this narrative and begin long before the day I first saw Josephine. Long before even the day I met Mr. Rust.
Certain events begat others, and these then followed on to more, a cascading flow of places and people, sorrow and guilt, a river that led me to you, and you to Jack, in ways that perhaps lend a purpose to the unspeakable tragedy that befell us. The tragedy that my hand delivered.
This is not a digression that I begin here, but a prelude of necessity to what came after. After I departed my brother’s house in disgrace, after I left respectable employ and became a spectacle of ridicule and contempt, after Mr. Rust found me shoeless and sick outside a tavern, after I tended to the fugitive Josephine.
But, before. Before.
Before, I had worked alongside a good and kind man, Dr. John Coggins.
Dr. Coggins was my professor at the medical college in Philadelphia. He instructed us in anatomy, medicinal herbs, and medicinal topography, his specialty. He was white-haired and whiskery, with sharp green eyes and a face lined like the body of a tortoise. Though he stood short of stature, his deep, grave voice and the very presence of him always seemed to me much larger than his physical size. In my memories he is always towering above, looking down at me as if from a great height.
I looked to him as I imagine a young man might look to a father. I do not think he ever regarded me in quite the same familial way, but he did take a shine to me. While a student, I often met him on weekends for walks along the banks of the Delaware and paths of Port Richmond Township. We would collect herbs and flowers and later press them between heavy gray sheets of paper bound with twine. This plant, he would tell me, is for bettering the spleen when mixed with arrowroot, or the bark of that tree helps ease a woman’s pain when birthing. I committed all his lessons to memory.
During my final year at the medical college, Dr. Coggins invited me to join him in bringing medicine to the rural folk throughout the small towns in southern Virginia. His plan was to establish a clinic in Randolph Township in Charlotte County. This was a place I knew well. My childhood had been spent in neighboring Lynnhurst, a town I had left at the age of 15, vowing never to return. Although eager to accept Dr. Coggins’s proposition, I was loath to return to that familiar region, full of failing tobacco fields, ruined mansions, the poorest folk in all the South, and the bitter memories I still held of my upbringing there. You see, my parents never developed a true fondness for me or my younger brother Jack, it being difficult for them to feed and clothe us adequately. I would not describe my early years as aggrieved, seeing as all my base physical needs were met, but I had no desire to extend the period of my youth any longer than was necessary. As soon as I could ride a day’s distance on horseback and knew how to fire a pistol, I set my departure.
I urged my brother Jack to accompany me. Although as distinct as potatoes and peas, we were as close as I believe two brothers could be. I saw no future for him if he stayed on our father’s meager farm. But Jack declined. He was but 13 when I left, and slight in size, his height had not yet taken. He looked still like a child, and it seemed the child in him could not foresee a life outside our parents’ house, no matter how oppressive that life might continue to be.
During my years away from home, working first in Philadelphia as a physician’s assistant and then later attending the medical college, I rarely thought of my parents. I wrote but once. My letter notified them of my place at the college and my intention to remain in Philadelphia until I earned my degree, perhaps longer.
My thoughts, however, turned often to Jack. I hoped he studied the books I had left. I hoped my father’s beatings had lessened in frequency and degree. I wondered when he might leave that place. But still, year after year, I did not write to him. I knew not the words to use.
It was Jack finally who sent word to me. In the spring of 1849 I received a letter informing me of my father’s death. Jack asked that I return home to pay respects to both my father and my already dead mother whose grave I had never seen. He explained that he had sold the family farm in Lynnhurst, purchased another in the neighboring town of Stanton, and recently married a woman whom we had known in childhood, Dorothea Rounds. It was Dorothea’s father, the undertaker, who had helped him with the burial of our mother and it was over our mother’s funeral rites that Jack had again met Dorothea.
Dorothea and Jack welcomed me to their marital home, he wrote. And so I came.